Kim Diamond
Jeffrey "Jeff" Patterson
Erica Geerson
Tristen Ryler
Stephen Ryan Parker
Sheriff Cravens
Eileen Treacle
Rustin Parr
Peggy
Reporter
Burkittsville Tourist
MBI Man
Stoner
Tourist
Kurt Loder
Chuck Scarborough
Self (archive footage)
Self (archive footage)
Burkittsville Resident #1
Burkittsville Tourist #2
Burkittsville Resident #2
Burkittsville Resident #3
Burkittsville Resident #4
Stoner #2
Foreigner #1
Foreigner #2
Doctor
Nurse
MBI Man #2
Teenager #1
Teenager #2
Teenager #3
Ham Lady
MBI Man #3
Reporter, Fox 45
Reporter
Reporter, WJZ 13
(voice)
Print Reporter
Angry Citizen at Courthouse
Doctor
Security Guard
First Nurse
Videographer
On Camera News Reporter
Hiker in Woods
Mental Patient
Photographer
Heather Donahue (archive footage) (uncredited)
Joshua Leonard (archive footage) (uncredited)
Michael Williams (archive footage) (uncredited)
Teenager #3