Ida Graber
Amy Roberts
Jill Green
Levi Brennaman
Henry Taskey
Rebecca Knepp
Katie Graber
Danny
Leonard
Rachel Knepp
Charlie Roberts
Mary Beth Graber
Gideon Graber
State Trooper
Judith
Minister
Shelly
Sheriff
Reporter
Teacher Ruth
Melinda
Sarah Knepp
Hannah
Jacob
Andy Roberts
Rachel's Husband
Melinda's Husband
Amish Elder
Knepp Boy #1
Knepp Boy #2
Ryan Roberts
Schoolboy (uncredited)
Lilly (uncredited)
Lydia (uncredited)
Knepp Teenager (uncredited)
Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)