Wild Bill Hickok/James Otis
Charlie Zane
Crazy Horse/Worm
Poker Jenny Schermerhorn
Whistling Jack Kileen
Winifred Coxy
Abel Pickney
Amos Briggs
Cassie Ollinger
Tim Brady
Pete Holt
Amos Bixby
Tom Custer
Jack McCall
Corporal Kileen
Frieda
Gyp Hook-Hand
Ben Corbett
Kid Jelly
Wes Pugh
Black Shawl
Old Worm
Aaron Pratt
Johnny Varner
Frozen Dog Pimp
Silky Smith
Cheyenne Bar Man
Frozen Dog Miner
Frozen Dog Miner
Paddy Welsh
Short Man (uncredited)
Bar Patron (uncredited)
Tall Man (uncredited)