Winifred Sanderson
Sarah Sanderson
Mary Sanderson
Becca
Izzy
Cassie
Mike
Gilbert
Billy Butcherson
Mayor / Reverend Traske
The Witch Mother
Young Winifred
Young Mary
Young Sarah
John Pritchett
Mr. Pritchett
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Mrs. Smith
Mr. Smith
Young Billy Butcherson
Mr. Wilke
School Secretary
Rob
Liam
Teen Winifred
Teen Mary
Teen Sarah
Thom
Teen Gilbert
Food Stall Woman
Fred
Lucas
Drag Queen Winifred
Drag Queen Mary
Drag Queen Sarah
Glenn
Alex
Liam's Mom
Scary Scarecrow
Roman Soldier
Puppeteer
Puppeteer
Puppeteer
Teacher (uncredited)