A recovering Kevin receives two surprise visitors. First Lucy comes by and the two say a heartful goodbye and close the door on their relationship. Eve then comes by, intent on declaring her feelings for him, and surprises him with a dinner for two. However, she misinterpets Lucy's visit and leaves. Later, Kevin catches up with her and invites her back to his place. Ellen gives Chris the date for his review board hearing. Lucy returns home and is given a surprise belated Christmas by Scott and Serena. Scott tries to give Lucy an out to their relationship, but she declares Scott and Serena are her family.

While trapped on an island, Joe and Courtney remember old times, then repair a raft to escape. However, Courtney twists her ankle before they depart the island. An old nemesis of Victor's traps him and Mary in the back of moving truck and plans to kill him. After failing to use laughing gas to overpower him, Mary personally appeals to the man, who agrees to help them because of his hatred toward Mr. Kanelos. After thanking Karen for her support during his withdrawal, Frank and Karen realize no one's heard from Joe and Courtney in Greece. They contact Mrs. Kanelos, who denies they are there.