Jack gets Livvie to see she loves him and not Caleb. After making love, Jack vows to fight Caleb if he returns. Ian learns Michael's not a real priest. After James dies, Lucy, Kevin and Rafe search for Caleb's talisman. They find a book on the Morley family and realize Caleb and Michael are the same person. Eve tells Michael she loves him, but not in a romantic way. Fearing for her safety, he makes her leave. Caleb appears and taunts Michael and they go for each other's throats. Eve returns but finds only Michael, who warns her Caleb's present. Michael then turns around and reveals HE IS CALEB!!

On the hospital roof, Caleb strangles Jack while Eve calls for ""Michael,"" who emerges. Gabriela arrives before Lucy can shoot Caleb with a stake. Pushing Gaby out of the way, Ian gets shot instead. Caleb grabs Eve and Livvie offers herself as a sacrifice. Eve again appeals for Michael, who's confused by the voices in his head. Pleading with God, Michael/Caleb is struck by lighting and turns to dust. Jack, Livvie and Gaby return to normal and Chris has no vampire symptoms. Everyone prays in the chapel. Eve weeps for Michael, then goes into premature labor. Livvie hears Caleb's voice and his ring appears in her hand.