In 2014, four women vanish from Chillicothe, Ohio. When two are later found dead, fears of a serial killer mount when a fifth woman goes missing in 2015. Before police can fully investigate the fifth missing woman, another body is found.

Another body is found during the search for the fifth missing woman; and an anonymous tip points the police to a possible suspect within hours.

The serial killer's possible dumping ground is discovered when a body is found in the same area as another found a year earlier; and a possible link between the victims is uncovered.

The police discover that one of the missing women knew one of the women found dead; and news of another missing girl sends Chillicothe into a panic.