Crystal Rogers’ car is abandoned in Bardstown, KY, the mother of 5 vanished. A year later her father is shot dead while searching for her. We discover there are multiple cases in a small town shrouded in secrets, and haunted by unsolved killings.

The brother of Crystal’s boyfriend, Nick Houck, a Bardstown Police Officer is grilled by the FBI. Stephanie and Dwayne follow a search of a lake where cadaver dogs pick up a scent. On the Bluegrass Parkway the scene of a deadly ambush is explored.

An FBI profiler offers chilling insights on a potential killer. Family members of Bardstown’s other victims speak. A mysterious white car is possibly linked to Crystal’s disappearance.